Creating Raving Fans Through Support (Even When The Customer is Wrong)

Let’s talk about the part of business that most people completely underestimate: what happens after someone buys from you.

Because here’s the truth—anyone can make a sale. That part’s not too hard (and it gets easier as you grow). But if you want to build a business that actually sustains itself (and doesn’t depend on you dancing on Instagram every day), you need to think bigger.

You need people talking about you when you’re not in the room.

Not just satisfied customers.

Raving fans.

The kind of people who keep coming back, tell their friends, and maybe make it a little weird in your DMs because they’re that obsessed with your work.

So how do you create that kind of loyalty?

It’s not about perfect tech.

It’s not about charming copy.

It’s about how you handle the moments where things don’t go perfectly.

Here’s what I’ve learned from being both the buyer and the seller—and why I’ll never treat customer support like an afterthought.

Because creating raving fans through support doesn’t happen by accident. It happens when your systems are clear, your emails show up, and your customers feel genuinely taken care of.

First Things First: Support is Part of the Product

I once paid $500 for a course that didn’t show up in my inbox.

No confirmation page.

No email.

No reassurance that it was coming.

Just an invoice.

So I reached out. And the response I got? Not helpful, apologetic, or even even remotely interested in solving the problem.

Just a defensive, “Did you check your spam?” and "Sorry I'm not glued to my laptop 24/7".

Look—people don’t drop money on a product for the chance of receiving it (unless we're talking about lotto tickets).

When someone buys from you—especially if they’ve been debating it for weeks like I was— they’re putting a certain level of trust in your hands. And from the minute we take their card info, that trust either grows or dissolves based on what happens next.

Creating Raving Fans Starts with Anticipating the Problems

You know what gets missed all the time?The five minutes after the sale.

Those few minutes are make-or-break. Your buyer is in that “Did I just get scammed?” stage. They want proof that they made a good decision. And if all they get is silence, it’s not a great look.

So here’s what I do—and what I recommend you set up:

• A clear, helpful thank-you page

• An immediate email that says exactly what they’ll get and when

• A backup plan for when something inevitably breaks

  
  

Because it will break. Even the best systems fail sometimes. That’s not the problem, nor is it usually within our control. The problem is pretending it’s fine when your customer says it’s not, OR burying your head in the sand.

What To Do When They’re Wrong (But Still Mad)

Let’s say the customer’s completely in the wrong.

Maybe they misread the sales page, or forgot to check their spam folder, or assumed they were getting something they absolutely were not promised.

Now what?

You have two options:

1. Be right

OR

2. Be generous

Guess which one turns a mildly annoyed buyer into a lifelong fan?

I’ve been on both sides of this. I’ve sent a pissy email thinking I was right, only to find out I wasn’t. And you know what turned me into a repeat customer anyway?

The seller gave me the thing I misunderstood—and didn’t make me feel like an idiot.

Not because she had to. And definitely not because I was entitled to it, because I wasn't. But because she understood that how her brand feels matters just as much as what it delivers.

She earned my trust—not by being perfect, but by being kind and empathetic.

Let’s Talk Systems

Look, you don’t have to be on-call 24/7 to create a great experience. But you can set up processes in place to help prevent some of those "oh crap, this isn't what I thought it was" moments.

Things like:

• Autoresponders that actually help:

  Even something short and sweet like, “Thanks for your email! If this is about login issues, click here to reset. If not, I’ll get back to you within 24 hours.”

  
  

• Templates for common problems Have canned responses ready that are empathetic, not robotic (and don't place blame).
  

• A backup plan for failed deliveries If your tech flops, do you know how to manually resend something? Does your customer know where to reach you? Fix that.
  

Creating a smooth system behind the scenes means your support can be helpful, even when you’re not glued to your laptop.

The Customer Is Sometimes Wrong—But That Doesn’t Matter

You don’t need to be a doormat. AndI’m not saying you have to give away the farm every time someone complains.

But I am saying that when you have the chance to go a little above what’s expected—even when the expectation is unreasonable—you can flip the entire dynamic.

You can take a pissed-off customer and turn them into a brand ambassador. You can turn a refund request into a referral engine.

And that? That’s real business strategy. Not just “being nice.”

What This Looks Like in Practice

Think about your own process:

• What does a new buyer see after they purchase?

• What do they receive, and when?

• What happens when something breaks?

• What’s the tone of your replies—especially when you’re tired or frustrated?

  
  

If you want people to keep coming back, these are the moments that matter.

Not the launch. Not the sales page. Not the fancy funnel. It’s what you do when your customer says, “Hey… something’s off.”

And how you respond when they’re not even right about what went wrong.

Final Thoughts: How to Create Raving Fans Through Support

• Make your post-purchase process clear—spell out what they can expect

• Reassure people the minute they buy

• Respond with kindness, not defensiveness—even when you’re right

• Use systems to make support sustainable

• Overdeliver when it counts (especially if they’re already upset)

  
  

This is how reputations are built.

It’s how customers become raving fans.

It’s how people end up saying your name in rooms you’re not even in.

And that? That’s the kind of growth that lasts.

Want More Support?

If you want help building your business, I’m here for that—let's get you set up to thrive.

And if you found this helpful, I’d love to send more guidance straight to your inbox—honest, thoughtful insights for women building coaching businesses with heart and intention.

📩 Join my email list here for weekly encouragement, strategy, and tools to keep you moving—one clear step at a time.